Daniel Garcia is the chief compliance officer of Kaiser Permanente, a sort of “chief investigator” for the organization. He was hired into that position, a position he helped create, in 2002. His history with Kaiser Permanente, however, dates back to 1992, when he first became a member of the organization’s Board of Directors. He continued to serve as an outside and independent director until he became chief compliance officer on February 1, 2002.
What is interesting about Mr. Garcia’s role at the organization is that he reports to the chief executive officer, George Halvorson and is also responsible for investigating Mr. Halvorson’s conduct. This reciprocal reporting relationship is not unique, however, and similar situations exist at many other organizations and companies. What is troubling, however, is the disturbing role Mr. Garcia played in hiring Mr. Halvorson, the significant resulting conflict of interest, and Mr. Garcia’s alarming history in Los Angeles politics, which is littered with serious allegations of corruption. In fact, it appears Mr. Garcia has never met a potential conflict of interest he didn’t like, but more on that in a moment…
When Mr. Halvorson was recently forced to address the mutual conflict of interest, he, again, mislead Kaiser Permanente employees by leaving out key details. Mr. Halvorson admitted that Mr. Garcia was “was on the committee that recommended that I be hired.” In fact, Mr. Garcia was the chair of the committee that hired Mr. Halvorson.
Mr. Halvorson went on to insist that “It’s…naïve, however, to say that Dan can’t subsequently do his job [as the chief of] compliance because of that prior committee role.” Mr. Halvorson insisted that he believes that demanding otherwise would mean that “any Board member on a search committee would be unable to make future decisions and judgments about people they had voted for in a search process.”
His straw man argument couldn’t be weaker. Here’s why…
Continue reading this post at the relaunched FixKP blog.
Comments for this post are disabled. Please comment at FixKP, instead.